Saw Palmetto vs Finasteride for Prostate: An Honest Comparison

When my doctor mentioned finasteride, the first thing I did when I got home was search “saw palmetto vs finasteride”. I wanted to know if the herb could do the same job without a prescription and without the side effects I had read about.

What I found was a story that changed over twenty years of research, and most articles only tell half of it. Here is the whole thing, with the studies linked. I am not a doctor, and this page is not a reason to start or stop any medicine. It is what the evidence says, so you can have a better conversation with yours.

On the best current evidence, finasteride is more effective. In a four year trial it cut the need for prostate surgery and urinary retention roughly in half. Saw palmetto alone did no better than placebo in the largest trials. Saw palmetto has fewer side effects, but it is not a substitute for finasteride.

Saw palmetto vs finasteride for BPH: side by side

Finasteride Saw palmetto (alone)
What it is Prescription medicine Plant extract, sold as a supplement
Best evidence Large, long trials Large trials and reviews
Result Fewer surgeries and less urinary retention over 4 years Little or no benefit over placebo in the largest trials
Time to work At least 6 months Studied over months
Side effects Can include sexual side effects Mild and infrequent

What finasteride does

Finasteride is one of the medicines the NIDDK lists for an enlarged prostate: it helps stop the prostate growing or shrinks it, which improves urine flow.

The headline study is a four year trial in the New England Journal of Medicine with about 3,000 men. Compared with placebo, finasteride cut the need for prostate surgery by 55% and the risk of acute urinary retention (suddenly not being able to pee) by 57%. Symptoms improved more than with placebo too.

It is not instant. MedlinePlus says it may take at least 6 months for symptoms to improve, and that it controls the condition rather than curing it.

Saw palmetto vs finasteride side effects

This is where saw palmetto has the edge, and it is the main reason men look for an alternative.

Finasteride. MedlinePlus lists possible side effects that include trouble getting or keeping an erection, lower sexual desire and problems with ejaculation, and notes they may continue after the medicine is stopped. That is worth a frank conversation with your doctor before you start.

Saw palmetto. The NCCIH says it is well tolerated, with mild and infrequent side effects such as stomach upset, dizziness and headache.

So “is saw palmetto safer than finasteride?” Fewer side effects, yes. But safer is not the same as effective, which brings us to the half of the story most articles skip.

Is saw palmetto as effective as finasteride?

Here is how the research changed:

The early studies looked good. A 2002 Cochrane review of 21 smaller trials concluded saw palmetto gave mild to moderate improvement, and similar improvement to finasteride with fewer side effects. That review is still quoted on a lot of supplement websites.

The bigger, better studies did not hold up. When researchers ran larger and longer trials, saw palmetto alone stopped beating placebo. The 2012 Cochrane update found it did not improve urine flow or prostate size, even at double and triple doses. A 2011 trial in JAMA found no benefit over placebo at up to 960 mg a day. And the NCCIH summarizes a 2023 review of 27 studies the same way: little or no benefit when saw palmetto is taken alone.

So the honest answer is no. On the best evidence we have today, saw palmetto on its own is not as effective as finasteride.

Where a supplement fits, honestly

None of that means supplements have no place. It means picking the right role and the right ingredients.

The role: for men with mild symptoms who want to try something at home, or alongside what their doctor prescribes, never in place of it. Do not stop or skip finasteride to try a supplement without talking to your doctor.

The ingredients: not saw palmetto alone. The ingredients with the better evidence are plant sterols and pygeum, each with a Cochrane review showing improvement. I go through all of them in do prostate supplements work.

That is why the formula I take combines plant sterols, pygeum, pumpkin seed and nettle with the saw palmetto, and comes with a 60 day money back guarantee so the trial costs nothing if it does not help. Everything about it, the complaints included, is in my ProstaFense review. Tell your doctor before you start, since the NCCIH notes some herbs and medicines interact.

Saw palmetto vs finasteride: what to take from Reddit

If you search “saw palmetto vs finasteride reddit”, notice that a large share of those threads are about hair loss, not the prostate, because both are used for it. Advice about a receding hairline tells you nothing about getting up at night. For the prostate threads, ask what the man actually took, for how long, and whether his doctor was involved.

Frequently asked questions

Is saw palmetto better than finasteride for BPH? No. On current evidence, finasteride is more effective: it cut the need for surgery and urinary retention roughly in half in a four year trial, while saw palmetto alone did no better than placebo in the largest trials.

Is saw palmetto safer than finasteride? It has fewer side effects. The NCCIH describes them as mild and infrequent, while finasteride can cause sexual side effects. But fewer side effects does not mean it works as well.

Can I take saw palmetto instead of finasteride? Not without talking to your doctor. The evidence does not support saw palmetto alone as a replacement. A supplement can be something to try alongside medical care, never in place of it.

Can you take saw palmetto and finasteride together? Ask your doctor first. The NCCIH notes that some herbs and medicines interact, and your doctor knows the rest of what you take.

How long does finasteride take to work for BPH? According to MedlinePlus, it may take at least 6 months for symptoms to improve, and it controls the condition rather than curing it.

Keep reading

Dale Prescott is a retired structural engineer in Fort Collins, Colorado. He is not a medical professional, and nothing on this page is medical advice. Never start, stop or change a prescription medicine without talking to your doctor. Dietary supplements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration and are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease. Some pages on this site contain affiliate links, which means The Night Flow Report may earn a commission if you buy through them, at no extra cost to you.

About the author

Dale Prescott is a retired structural engineer in Fort Collins, Colorado. He spent three years getting up two to four times a night before he did anything about it, and he kept a log the whole time. He is not a medical professional.